This Post Has 0 Comments

1. Muhammaad 'Ali April 19, 2019 Reply

   Mufti Muhammad Taqi Usmani has written in his ‘Uloomu–l-Qur’aan (An Approach to the Qur’aanic Sciences) (page 469-470):

   …when Muhammad Ibn Marwaan As-Suddi As-Sagheer reports from Kalbi, this is regarded by the authorities as a false sequence … It is wrong to ascribe it to Ibn Abbas because this book has been based on the reported sequence of Muhammad Ibn Marwaan As-Suddi from Muhammad Ibn Saa’ib Al-Kalbi from Abi Salih from Ibn Abbas (R) … this has been regarded by the Muhadditheen as “chain of falsehood” and hence cannot be relied upon.